His endless illegal actions may not not rise to the level of indiscriminate boater murders and the illegal mass murder of children, but Brendan Carr’s impeachment should very much be a priority. That’s the position of Reporters Without Borders (RWB), which last week called for Democrats — in the wake of their landslide midterm victories — to impeach FCC boss Brendan Carr in the new year.
It’s their first ever such call in the history of the organization:
“Carr’s tenure as FCC Chair has been defined by his campaign to intimidate and punish media organizations disfavored by the president. He has launched baseless investigations into news organizations, seized on vaguely written regulations to punish news outlets for speech deemed anti-Trump, threatened the broadcast licenses of TV and radio networks based on their editorial lines, gutted rules against media ownership consolidation, put his thumb on the scales of massive media mergers to benefit Trump allies, and improperly supported midterm campaigns. His consistent abuse of his office demands urgent action from Congress.”
Carr’s effort to roll back America’s already shaky media consolidation limits is a very clear, illegal act that undermines the will of Congress. As is stuff like Carr’s illegal efforts to dismantle the FCC’s E-Rate program, which provides affordable internet access to rural schools, libraries, and communities.
And who can forget Carr’s illegal, unconstitutional assault on ABC for the “crime” of platforming journalism and comedians that dared make fun of the increasingly unpopular president. In that instance, ABC and Disney have provided evidence that Carr covertly worked with Trump-friendly TV broadcasters to pretend ABC broke the law — simply because the network aired an interview with Texas Senator elect James Talarico (particularly fertile ground for oversight subpoenas in the new year).
There are also numerous instances where Carr very clearly violated the Hatch Act, most recently when he he illegally leveraged his authority during a political rally for Alaska Republican Senate candidate Dan Sullivan. From the RWB statement:
“The American people have decisively rejected the Trump administration’s trampling of the Constitution. Few individuals have been more instrumental to the White House’s campaign to weaken the First Amendment than Brendan Carr. The incoming Congress now faces a defining test of its commitment to the Constitution and the freedoms it guarantees. Press freedom cannot be defended through words alone. RSF does not take the question of impeachment lightly. In fact, our organization has never before called for the removal of a US official. But the severity and persistence of Carr’s misconduct demand an extraordinary response. Congress has a constitutional responsibility to hold him accountable. Restoring the FCC’s independence must be central to that effort.“
There’s endless other stuff that tends to be obscured in the media by Carr’s ham-fisted attacks on free speech, whether it’s the way he’s made life easier on robocallers (while pretending to be tough on robocallers) and shitty prison telecom monopolies, stripped away every last shred of (already flimsy) U.S. oversight of our lumbering, unpopular broadband monopolies, rubber stamped endlessly harmful mergers, or turned a blind eye to the foreign-influence concerns of the recent Paramount/Warner Bros deal.
On one hand, Carr’s “policies” on telecom and media are utterly indistinguishable from industry. He’s never seen an AT&T or Comcast policy he hasn’t adopted as his own. But Carr’s unique in that he’s also an unapologetic fascist and bigot, and has spent a lot of time during his tenure demanding that telecom and media giants be more racist and sexist if they want their terrible, pointless mergers approved.
Trump’s first term FCC boss, Ajit Pai, was a textbook example of obvious regulatory capture, building an FCC dedicated exclusively to the interests of the biggest media and telecom giants. Carr’s similarly compromised, but his tenure has also been infused not just with dangerous and illegal authoritarian zealotry, but the sort of lame, edgelord meme-slinging you’d expect of a dim highschooler.
There’s simply no shortage of ammunition for investigations and impeachment in the new year. Without it, things will not only get decidedly worse for free speech and consumer protection, but the closest Carr will get to “accountability” is some post-FCC high six-figure gig at a telecom or media industry think tank, where he’ll spend the rest of his days using what’s left of his credibility to further ratfuck competition, consumers, and free speech.
If there’s ever somebody desperately in need of “making an example of” by a reconstituted Congress, it’s Carr.